A settlement fail occurs when either the securities or cash are not delivered by the required settlement date (after T+2). Fails can result from various operational, technical, or funding issues and require specific resolution procedures while potentially incurring penalties and regulatory reporting requirements.
Fail CategoriesType Description Primary Cause Securities Fail Unable to deliver securities Position shortage Cash Fail Unable to deliver payment Funding issues Technical Fail System/processing issues Operational problems Administrative Fail Documentation/instruction issues Processing errors
Impact Assessment
Impact Area Effect Consequence Regulatory Reporting requirement Compliance action Financial Fail charges/penaltiesCost impact Operational Additional processing Resource drain Relationship Client/counterparty impact Reputation risk
Resolution Process
Stage Action Timeline Identification Fail recognitionImmediate Investigation Root cause analysis Day of fail Communication Stakeholder notification Same day Resolution Corrective action ASAP Documentation Record keeping Throughout
Risk Management
Risk Type Description Mitigation Financial Risk Penalty exposure Early resolution Regulatory RiskCompliance issues Proper reporting Operational Risk Processing impact Process improvement Reputational Risk Client relationship Communication plan
Best Practices
Fail Prevention:
Early monitoring
Proactive management
Position verification
Funding confirmation
Resolution Management:
Quick identification
Root cause analysis
Prompt communication
Effective resolution
Documentation:
Complete records
Resolution tracking
Cost recording
Report filing
Requirement Timing Action Fail ReportingDaily Submit reports Resolution Updates Ongoing Status updates Cost Recording Per incident Fee calculation Documentation Throughout Record keeping
Cost Implications
Cost Type Description Impact Fail ChargesRegulatory penaltiesDirect cost Interest Claims Funding costs Financial impact Operational Costs Additional processing Resource cost Buy-in Costs Forced purchase Market impact
Communication Protocol
Stakeholder Timing Method Counterparty Immediate Direct contact Regulators As required Official reporting Internal Teams Same day Status updates Management Daily Summary reports
Resolution Strategies
Securities Fails:
Borrowing arrangements
Alternative delivery
Buy-in procedures
Position reconciliation
Cash Fails:
Funding solutions
Payment prioritization
Credit arrangements
Treasury management
Technical Fails:
System fixes
Process corrections
Instruction updates
Documentation review
Performance Metrics
Metric Description Target Resolution Time Time to resolve Same day Cost Impact Financial effect Minimize Recurrence Rate Repeat fails Zero Reporting Accuracy Documentation quality 100%
Documentation Requirements
Document Purpose Timing Fail NoticeInitial recording Day of fail Resolution Plan Action steps Same day Status Updates Progress tracking Daily Final Report Resolution record Upon completion
System Requirements
Monitoring Tools:
Fail identificationStatus tracking
Cost calculation
Report generation
Communication Systems:
Alert mechanisms
Update distribution
Status tracking
Report filing
Resolution Tools:
Action tracking
Cost recording
Documentation
Reporting
Success Factors
Prevention:
Early detection
Proactive management
Risk assessment
Control enhancement
Resolution:
Quick response
Effective action
Clear communication
Complete documentation
Learning:
Root cause analysis
Process improvement
Control enhancement
Training updates
Area Effect Management Liquidity Market efficiencyQuick resolution Confidence Market stabilityEffective handling Relationships Counterparty trust Clear communication Operations Processing efficiency Process improvement
Note: Fail management requirements can vary by market , instrument, and jurisdiction. Always verify specific requirements with relevant clearing organizations and regulators.
Every contribution fuels new features and improvements
Thank you for being part of our journey! 🚀
